How Criminal Charges Affect Child Custody Arrangements: Advice for Parents
Home / How Criminal Charges Affect Child Custody Arrangements: Advice for Parents
Our lawyers at The Australian Legal Practice are skilled in all your Family Law application needs. If you or someone you know need to apply for Family Law, contact us immediately on (02) 8084 9929.
Introduction
When criminal charges enter the picture in family law matters, the implications for child custody arrangements can be significant. Australian family courts prioritise the best interests of the child above all else, and criminal charges against a parent inevitably factor into these determinations.
The "Best Interests" Principle in Australian Family Law
In Australia, the Family Law Act 1975 establishes that all custody decisions must be made according to what is in the child’s best interests. This includes considerations of:
- The need to protect children from physical or psychological harm
- The benefit of maintaining meaningful relationships with both parents
- The capacity of each parent to provide for the child’s needs
Criminal charges and convictions directly impact how courts assess these factors.
How Different Types of Charges Affect Custody
Not all criminal charges carry the same weight in custody proceedings:
- Family violence offences: Domestic violence charges or AVOs (Apprehended Violence Orders) significantly impact custody arrangements, often resulting in supervised visits or contact restrictions.
- Child abuse or neglect: Charges related to harm of children typically lead to severe custody restrictions.
- Drug manufacturing or trafficking: These charges raise serious concerns about the home environment and parental capacity.
Moderate-Impact Charges:
- Drug possession: Courts assess the context, frequency, and rehabilitation efforts.
- Drink driving offences: Multiple offences may signal judgment issues relevant to parenting capacity.
- Property crimes: While less directly related to parenting, they may affect the court’s view of character and stability.
Immediate Effects of Criminal Charges
When charges are first laid:
1. Temporary Orders
The other parent may seek emergency custody modifications.
2. Bail Conditions
These may include restrictions on contacting children or visiting certain locations.
3. Court-mandated assessments
Family reports or psychological evaluations might be ordered.
Long-Term Consequences After Resolution
When charges are first laid:
1. If convicted
The court will consider the nature of the offence, sentencing, and rehabilitation efforts.
2. If acquitted
The allegations themselves may still be considered if relevant to child safety.
3. If charges are dropped
The circumstances may still be examined in family court.
Practical Advice for Parents Facing Charges
If You’re Facing Criminal Charges:
- Seek separate legal representation for both criminal and family law matters.
- Demonstrate rehabilitation through counselling, courses, or treatment programs.
- Document positive parenting through attendance at school events, medical appointments, and regular contact.
- Comply fully with any court orders, bail conditions, or intervention programs.
Maintain transparency with the family court about the status of criminal proceedings.
If Your Co-Parent Is Facing Charges
- Focus on child safety rather than punishing the other parent.
- Consider supervised visitation as a temporary measure during proceedings.
- Document relevant concerns specifically related to parenting capacity.
Avoid making unfounded allegations or using criminal charges vindictively.
How the Court Assesses Risk
Family courts typically consider:
- The nature and seriousness of the alleged conduct
- The timing and circumstances of the offence
- Any pattern of concerning behaviour
- Steps taken to address underlying issues
- Evidence of rehabilitation and behavioural change
Finding a Path Forward
Criminal charges don’t automatically disqualify someone from being an involved parent. Australian courts recognise that maintaining relationships with both parents is generally beneficial for children, provided it’s safe to do so.
Many parents successfully navigate these challenges by:
- Engaging with appropriate support services
- Complying with court-ordered programs
- Maintaining consistent, positive contact with children where permitted
- Demonstrating change through actions rather than promises
When to Modify Existing Orders
Existing parenting orders may need modification when:
- New charges arise that affect child safety
- There are significant changes in circumstances
- Current arrangements no longer serve the child’s best interests
Conclusion
Criminal charges inevitably complicate child custody matters, but the impact varies widely depending on the nature of the offence and the parent’s response. By focusing on rehabilitation, child safety, and positive parenting, many parents can maintain meaningful relationships with their children despite legal challenges.
If you’re navigating these complex waters, specialised legal advice from both family and criminal law practitioners is essential to achieving the best possible outcome for you and your children.
Our Family lawyers can help you today. Call (02) 8084 9929 to arrange a free initial consultation with a Family lawyer.
ONLINE ENQUIRY
Make a booking to arrange a free consult today.
Call A Lawyer NOw
AVAILABLE 24/7
