Can Mental Health Issues Get Your Criminal Charges Dropped in Australia?
Home / Criminal Charges Dropped in Australia
Quick Answer
Yes, in Australia mental health issues can result in criminal charges being dropped, and this is a legal pathway that most people do not realise exists.
In NSW, the main mechanism is a Section 14 order under the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW). If successful, the Local Court dismisses the charge without a conviction, without a finding of guilt, and without anything recorded on your criminal record, provided you comply with a treatment or support plan for up to 12 months.
How Mental Health Diversion Works in NSW
The Australian legal system recognises that punishing someone whose mental health or cognitive condition contributed to an offence is often not in the public interest. Treatment is more likely to prevent reoffending than conviction.
Pathway | What It Does | Where It Applies |
Section 14 order (MHCIFP Act 2020) | Court dismisses the charge and diverts you into treatment or support | Local Court, summary and some indictable offences |
Section 19 order (MHCIFP Act 2020) | Mentally ill or disordered persons transferred to a mental health facility | Local Court |
Special verdict (act proven but not criminally responsible) | Historically “not guilty by reason of mental illness” | Indictable matters in District or Supreme Court |
Fitness to be tried | Proceedings halted if a defendant cannot understand them | All jurisdictions |
Section 14 is by far the most commonly used mechanism and is the focus of this article.
Section 14 Orders: Who Is Eligible?
A Section 14 order is available if you have (or had at the time of the offence) a mental health impairment or cognitive impairment as defined by the Act.
Mental health impairments include anxiety disorders, clinical depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD, psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia, borderline personality disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and substance-induced disorders provided they are not temporary.
Cognitive impairments include intellectual disability, borderline intellectual functioning, autism spectrum disorder, acquired brain injury, dementia, drug or alcohol-related brain damage, foetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and ADHD in appropriate cases.
A mental health impairment caused solely by the temporary effect of ingesting a substance is excluded. A diagnosed substance use disorder on its own is also excluded, though substance-induced conditions that persist can qualify.
What the Magistrate Must Be Satisfied Of
Before making a Section 14 order, the Magistrate must be satisfied of two things:
- The defendant has or had a mental health impairment or cognitive impairment at the relevant time
- It is more appropriate to deal with the defendant under Section 14 than according to the criminal law
Under section 15 of the Act, the Magistrate considers the nature of the impairment, the seriousness and circumstances of the offence, available sentencing options, changes in the defendant’s circumstances, criminal history, any previous diversion orders, the quality of the treatment plan, and whether the defendant is likely to endanger themselves or others.
When Section 14 Is Most Likely to Succeed
Factors that support a successful application:
- Diagnosed condition confirmed by a forensic psychiatrist or psychologist
- Direct link between the condition and the offending behaviour
- Comprehensive treatment or support plan already in place
- Engagement with existing treatment
- Offence not at the serious end of the spectrum
Factors that make it harder:
- Serious violence or sexual offences
- Significant criminal history
- Weak or generic medical reports
- Previous breaches of similar orders
The quality of the psychiatric or psychological report is often decisive. A report from a forensic psychiatrist addressing the statutory criteria carries the most weight.
What Happens If the Application Succeeds
A successful Section 14 order has significant advantages:
- The charge is dismissed
- No finding of guilt is made
- No conviction is recorded
- Nothing appears on a standard National Police Check as a criminal record entry
- No mandatory penalty applies, including automatic licence disqualification for traffic offences
A Section 14 dismissal is technically more favourable than a Section 10 dismissal, because a Section 10 still involves a finding of guilt.
The Judge can discharge the defendant into the care of a responsible person (with or without conditions), on the condition of attending for treatment or support, or unconditionally.
What Happens If You Breach the Conditions
If you breach the conditions of a Section 14 order within 12 months, the Judge can bring the matter back before the court and deal with the original charge in the ordinary way.
This means the prosecution can proceed, a finding of guilt can be made, and a conviction can be recorded, as if the Section 14 order had never existed.
What About Serious Indictable Offences?
Section 14 is only available in the Local Court. It is not available for serious matters in the District or Supreme Court.
For serious indictable offences where mental health is relevant, the options include:
- Special verdict of “act proven but not criminally responsible because of mental health impairment or cognitive impairment” (Part 4 of the MHCIFP Act 2020), previously known as not guilty by reason of mental illness
- Fitness to be tried inquiry if the defendant cannot understand proceedings or make a defence
- Mental health as a mitigating factor at sentencing, which can reduce penalty but does not avoid conviction
A successful special verdict does not result in a simple acquittal. The defendant typically becomes a forensic patient under supervision of the Mental Health Review Tribunal.
Mental Health at Sentencing
Even if charges are not dismissed, mental health can significantly affect sentencing. Courts routinely treat mental health impairment as a mitigating factor, particularly where the condition contributed to the offending, where custody would be more onerous due to the condition, or where rehabilitation is a realistic prospect with treatment. The principles from R v Verdins are often cited, including reduced moral culpability and reduced weight on deterrence where mental impairment is established.
Final Thoughts
Mental health issues can absolutely result in criminal charges being dismissed in Australia, and the Section 14 pathway in NSW is one of the most underused legal tools in the system. For people with genuine mental health or cognitive conditions, this is a legitimate alternative to conviction that prioritises treatment over punishment and leaves no criminal record.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Section 14 order?
A Section 14 order is made by a Local Court Judge under the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW). It dismisses a criminal charge and diverts the defendant into treatment or support. No conviction, no finding of guilt, and nothing on a standard criminal record.
Which conditions qualify for a Section 14 order?
Qualifying conditions include anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD, psychotic disorders, autism spectrum disorder, intellectual disability, acquired brain injury, dementia, and ADHD in appropriate cases. Substance use disorders alone do not qualify, but substance-induced conditions that persist can.
Does Section 14 apply to all criminal charges?
No. Section 14 applies only to summary offences and indictable offences tried summarily in the Local Court. It does not apply to serious indictable matters heard in the District or Supreme Court.
What happens if I don’t comply with a Section 14 treatment plan?
If you breach the conditions within 12 months, the Judge can bring the matter back and deal with the original charge in the usual way, which can result in conviction and sentence.
Is Section 14 the same as the old Section 32?
Section 14 replaced the former Section 32 under the Mental Health (Forensic Provisions) Act 1990 when the new Act commenced. The overall mechanism is similar, but Section 14 has updated definitions, an extended 12-month monitoring period (up from 6 months), and a codified list of factors the Judge must consider.
If your matter is urgent, call (02) 8084 9929 today to arrange a free initial consultation.
Criminal Law Locations
ONLINE ENQUIRY
Make a booking to arrange a free consult today.
Call A Lawyer NOw
AVAILABLE 24/7
